Best Sellers

Skip to results list
18 items

Filter

  • 10" Birthday Cake
    Sale

    10" Birthday Cake K1

    10" Birthday Cake K1
    $41.98
    $41.98 $140.01

    Product overview You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling Birthday Cake, inspired...
  • Assorted Cookie Tin - 12 Count
    Sale

    Assorted Cookie Tin - 12 Count N2

    Assorted Cookie Tin - 12 Count N2
    $14.39
    $14.39 $48.02

    Item information What’s better than one of each cookie? Two of each. This 12-count cookie...
  • Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count
    Sale

    Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count Y0

    Assorted Cookie Tin - 6 Count Y0
    $8.39
    $8.39 $28.02

    Item information Sometimes the correct answer is “one of each.” So we put together a...
  • Front view of a 6" Birthday Cake
    Sale

    6" Birthday Cake Z2

    6" Birthday Cake Z2
    $19.49
    $19.49 $64.99

    Item information You’ve never tried a birthday cake like this. Our bestselling Birthday Cake, inspired...
  • Gluten Free Birthday Cake Front
    Sale

    6" Gluten-Free Birthday Cake I8

    6" Gluten-Free Birthday Cake I8
    $23.41
    $23.41 $77.98

    Item overview Our classic Birthday Cake, inspired by the supermarket stuff we grew up with...
  • A pile of birthday cake truffles sitting on top of a milk bar branded box.
    Sale

    B'Day Truffle Dozen Box W4

    B'Day Truffle Dozen Box W4
    $12.01
    $12.01 $39.98

    Product details We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake into a single...
  • Birthday Truffle Gift Pack
    Sale

    Birthday Truffle Gift Pack N6

    Birthday Truffle Gift Pack N6
    $12.88
    $12.88 $42.98

    Product overview We rolled all the childhood flavor of our signature cake into these rainbow-flecked,...
  • SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie
    Sale

    SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie Q5

    SKIPPY® Peanut Butter Crunch Pie Q5
    $17.41
    $17.41 $58.01

    Item information Our Chocolate PB Crunch Pie starts with a filling made from the crunchy...
  • The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count
    Sale

    The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count F5

    The Cookie Faves Tin - 12 Count F5
    $14.41
    $14.41 $47.99

    Item overview Look, we got all your favorites together! The Cookie Faves Tin is packed...
  • The Double Truffle
    Sale

    The Double Truffle U6

    The Double Truffle U6
    $22.21
    $22.21 $74.01

    Product details We doubled down on our truffle game for this megapack of bite-sized beauties....
  • Greatest Hits Duo
    Sale

    Greatest Hits Duo Q4

    Greatest Hits Duo Q4
    $26.09
    $26.09 $86.99

    Product details If we believed in popularity contests, these fan favorites would win. The best-selling...
  • The Milk Bar Sampler
    Sale

    The Milk Bar Sampler W7

    The Milk Bar Sampler W7
    $17.99
    $17.99 $60.02

    Product overview Have a little bit of everything! This sampler pack of classic Milk Bar...
  • Milk Bar® Pie
    Sale

    Milk Bar® Pie Q6

    Milk Bar® Pie Q6
    $15.88
    $15.88 $53.01

    Item information This cult classic put Milk Bar on the map. It has has a...
  • The Sweet Spot
    Sale

    The Sweet Spot I7

    The Sweet Spot I7
    $33.28
    $33.28 $111.02

    Product overview Not too big, but definitely not too small — you’ll always hit The...
  • The Sweetie
    Sale

    The Sweetie S9

    The Sweetie S9
    $26.11
    $26.11 $87.02

    Item information Be a dear, please a crowd. The Sweetie is jam-packed with fan favorites...
  • The Big B’Day Gift
    Sale

    The Big B’Day Gift W6

    The Big B’Day Gift W6
    $28.52
    $28.52 $95.02

    Product details A birthday-flavored no-brainer that brings together all the heavy hitters for an all-out...
  • A 6" Birthday Cake next to a pile of b'day cake truffles.
    Sale

    The Birthday Classic O7

    The Birthday Classic O7
    $29.11
    $29.11 $96.98

    Product overview A birthday-flavored no-brainer fit for any kind of celebration. 1 Birthday Cake +...
  • 6" Birthday Cake, Milk Bar Pie and Birthday Truffle Dozen Box
    Sale

    The Newbie M3

    The Newbie M3
    $43.81
    $43.81 $145.98

    Item overview This can’t-fail starter pack is ideal for initiating Milk Bar rookies into the...